|
 Caretaker, The (2008)
IMDB rating: 3.60
Plot: A bunch of teenagers is trying to frighten their girls at night amidst a rundown garden where an old house hides something wild and terrific.
|
Directors: Olson Bryce
Actors: Immekus James,St. John Andrew,Torres Diego J.,Nelson Judd,Breck Jonathan,Stiles Will,Ashton Rene,Andrews Shawn,Cromedy Jahkeim,MacMullan Rob,Comedy,Horror,
Is it appropriate to ask a sitter to go to bed earlier the night before watching a child?
I watch my nephew one day a week (for free and I miss out on working that day) for my sister and sometimes I will sleep over to make it easier for the transition in the morning. Well, last week we were all up late (about midnight) and she and her husband went to bed but I still had a couple little things to do before going to sleep. Well the next day, the baby (who is 2) was exceptionally unruly and would not sleep. When my sister asked how it was going I told her what was going on. The day after that she, out of no where, said "you know, I would really appreciate it if you would go to bed earlier when you’ll be watching my child the next day so you won’t get so frustrated with him". I am 25 years old, I have been a nanny for the past 13 years, I am the most responsible person in my family when it comes to work, and I know how much sleep I need to get, yet she still felt the need to say that. Although he is normally a super sweet lovable little boy, he can be a monster sometimes and she is completely blind to any fault in her child, whether it’s just a bad day or he is being a terror.
He is always loved, well fed, has had his naps, has play time, and is genuinely well taken care of when in my care.
She says that it’s her right as a parent to ask whatever she wants of her caretaker. Am I wrong for finding that slightly offensive and out of line?
I should probably mention that he was a premie and that he is her first child….
We tease her because her excuse for everything from temper tantrums to just being a punk is "he was a premie!" or "you don’t want a completely obedient child, that’s not normal!" "he’s just being a little boy"…..
I love him to death and think he’s an awesome little guy, but he does have his moments.
I don’t think that’s right. It doesn’t sound like you "not sleeping" wasn’t the problem. Sounds like he was just having a cranky day. I’d just ignore her. Yes parents can ask things of their children’s caretaker, but as long as it’s within reason.
Amy M | Feb 01, 2010
Just say Yes and do whatever you want. She can’t monitor your sleeping schedule.
Auditore da Firenze | Feb 01, 2010
yes you have the right to be upset. i would have politely said what i do in my personal life when your child is not in my care is none of your business. i don’t tell you how to live your life please don’t tell me how to live mine or you could always find another sitter.
Natasha | Feb 01, 2010
Tell her to find another caretaker. You are doing her and her husband a favor (even if your the aunt). There are extreams though. If she was up with you she has no complaint. If on the other side you went to a biker bar til 4am stumbeling home to watch the kid the next day she could have a point.
Cletus | Feb 01, 2010
Well…if it were a hired person…I think it would be out of line…
But if it was my sister…I’d probably tell her the same thing.
Whether you want to believe it or not, and whether it was appropriate or not…your sister is right. YOU WILL be less patient if you’re wiped out too.
I’m not saying that your sister had any right to tell you when to go to bed and I’m not saying that your nephew wasn’t being a bloody terror that particular day…but I can tell you….because I’m the mother of a toddler that has his moments…WHEN I DON’T SLEEP…we all suffer.
If I were you…I’d not spend the night before hand.
If she wants to treat you like a caretaker…then come in at 8AM or whatever time…like a "Caretaker" would.
And while she has the right as a parent to ask whatever she wants…you as a caretaker don’t have to comply just because she’s asking.
I can see both sides of it.
Yes it’s a pushy request….but it’s also good advice….so I don’t know what to tell ya…lol.
?Silly 2? Due 3/17/2010 | Feb 01, 2010
if she feels that you are not fit for taking care of her child then she can pay for someone to watch him. You are fine and can take care of your self. however if you neglected the child while you watched it she can ask you but never demand you you are your own person. she cant make you do any thing.
Ben | Feb 01, 2010
No she doesn’t have that right even if she were paying you and she isn’t even doing that. It sounds to me like she is not blind to the child’s behavior but that she doesn’t want to admit to it and so instead she makes it out to be your fault for not being patient when the real issue is how her child was behaving. She will sadly be one of those parents who is always making excuses for and covering up for their child and their behavior instead of working toward correcting it. If you are giving up paid work to babysit for free then I just wouldn’t do it anymore. If she wants to be that picky with who watches her child and what time they go to bed the night before she better start paying someone else to do it and even then she won’t find anyone who would allow her to dictate to them what time they need to go to bed the night before.
luvmy4boyz | Feb 01, 2010
She can ask and you can decline to babysit for her.
I can’t blame her for not wanting an overtired person babysitting and I can’t blame you for being irked that she thinks you don’t know your own limits. Neither of you is wrong, per se, you’re just not suited to work for her.
Carrie | Feb 01, 2010
It is not her right to ask "whatever she wants" of her child’s caretaker. It IS her right to ask her child’s caretakers to meet certain standards of care, however. For instance, if she prefers that her child’s caretakers not yell or spank, then she has the right to ask that, and it is up to the caregiver to meet those requirements. Then, if YOU, as the caregiver, feel that getting more sleep would help you meet those requirements, then YOU can make that choice.
Sit her down and tell her that if she has a problem with something you are doing (or not doing) that specifically relates to her child, she needs to address it with you directly — how much sleep you get or don’t get on your own time is not something she gets to decide.
Jill P | Feb 01, 2010
Yes,she does have a right as a parent to ask whatever she wants of her caretaker when she is "paying" that person and her demands are within reason. Since she is not, I suggest that you, your sister and brother-in-law have a sit down and discuss this. Better solution, let her hire a caretaker.
Deevil | Feb 01, 2010
Hi ya…if this were MY sister…she would have gotten a reaming! She has absolutely NO right to tell you how to live your life, especially since you are doing this for FREE…it sure sounds like you are doing a great job and you know what, it is ok to have a bad day!! Everyone has bad days, even little ones. Just don’t tell her how your day is going…truly…now you know how she will react. Just tell her everything is fine. Confide in a close friend or spouse when you need to vent…treat her like your employer. Maybe you should start charging her! Wow, she had a lot of nerve..i am upset and don’t know you guys from a hole in the wall! lol But anyway, I digress…off my soap box… Bottom line, you are doing a good job by your nephew! leave it at that. If your sister persists, then give her notice…she can find another sitter. I wish you good luck and hope things work out for you.

evieluvsu | Feb 01, 2010
If you are at her house I think she has the right to ask you to go to bed at a reasonable hour. — I tell my friends when to have the lights out and TV off because it’s my house, my rules. (Plus I have a hard time sleeping if I know someone is up in my house.)
However, as long as it isn’t affecting the care her son is getting, she does not have the right to ask you, as the sitter, to go to bed early.
So nights that you are at her house — Yes, I think it is appropriate for her to ask you to go to bed at a certain time. But you can point out that this is too early for you and you were just staying the night as a convenience for her.
Nights that you are at your own home — It really isn’t her business.
About what she said … It is her right as a parent to ask whatever she wants of her caretaker. But before opening her mouth, she needs to ask herself if this issue is worth finding a new caretaker over. Because she can’t rule your life. She can say "If you want to watch my son, I need you to ____". If you don’t agree, she should be ready to find someone else.
Michelle | Feb 01, 2010
You should tell your sister that you are a big girl and can decide when your bedtime should be.Also let her know that you were frustrated because HE was the one who wouldn’t sleep and was being difficult.If she can’t believe that her precious little angel has off days, then she is naive.It had no bearing on your bedtime.Also remind her that you are doing this for FREE and if she has a problem with the arrangement, then she can feel free to find a new babysitter.
nelawala | Feb 01, 2010